Helical Head vs Straight Knife Cutterheads

A helical head planer and a straight knife planer are two different types of woodworking tools used for thicknessing wood. Here are the key differences between the two:

1. Blade design: The most significant difference between the two planers is the design of the cutting blades. A helical head planer uses a series of small, square-shaped inserts arranged in a spiral pattern around the cutterhead. In contrast, a straight knife planer uses long, straight blades that are mounted parallel to each other on the cutterhead.
2. Cutting action: The cutting action of a helical head planer is more of a shearing action, which results in a smoother finish and less tear-out, especially on figured or difficult-to-plane wood. On the other hand, a straight knife planer uses a slicing action, which can sometimes cause tear-out, particularly on figured wood.
3. Noise and vibration: Helical head planers generally produce less noise and vibration compared to straight knife planers due to their design and cutting action. This can make them more comfortable to use for extended periods.
   
4. However there is a shadow pattern caused by helical heads, which can be observed in certain conditions. The helical head design, with its rows of square carbide inserts arranged in a spiral pattern around the cutterhead, can create a unique shadow pattern on the wood surface. This pattern is a result of the cutting action of the individual inserts as they shear the wood fibers.
   
5. Blade replacement and maintenance: The individual inserts on a helical head planer can be rotated or replaced as needed, which can extend the life of the cutterhead. Depending on the size of the cutterhead it be time intensive to change the many small knives individually. Straight knife planers require the entire blade to be replaced when it becomes dull or damaged. However, the cost of replacing a straight knife is typically less than the cost of replacing multiple inserts on a helical head planer.
6. Price: Helical head planers are generally more expensive than straight knife planers due to their more complex design and the cost of the individual inserts.

In summary, helical head planers offer a smoother finish, reduced tear-out, and lower noise and vibration levels compared to straight knife planers. However, they are typically more expensive, may cause a shadowing pattern and may require more maintenance in terms of replacing the inserts. Straight knife planers are more affordable and easier to maintain but may not provide the same level of finish and can be more prone to tear-out on figured wood.

​

• Related Articles

• Morbidelli N100

  Air Treatment Unit ** To maximize the life of your pneumatic systems on your CNC it is ideal to have dry air filters inline with your compressor connected to your machine! ** Vacuum Pump ** Bearings should be greased with the grease tube provided ~ 2 ...

• New Edgebander Plan

  Paying a little attention to proper setup and regular maintenance will go along way to keeping your edgebander productive. Edgebanders are the central machine in today’s panel-driven cabinet shop, but they are a complex machine and have a reputation ...

• Things to look for when choosing an edgebander

  If you are in the market for a new edgebander here are a few of the questions to ask yourself and what to look for when shopping. What thickness of edges am I looking to apply? Basic edgebanders are intended for applying thin tape (around .5mm) As ...